Supreme Court of Pakistan
2025
THLN 5480
2025 PTD 260 | 2025 SCMR 121 | 2025 PTCL 209
Laws Cited
Customs Act, 1969
Sections
First Sched, 18, 33

ADDITIONAL COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS, MODEL CUSTOMS COLLECTORATE OF APPRAISEMENT (WEST), CUSTOM HOUSE, KARACHI

VS

Messrs K.S. SULEMANJI ESMAILJI AND SONS (PVT.) LTD. KARACHI

Petitioner(s) by: Raja Muhammad Iqbal, Advocate Supreme Court along with Ch. M. Javed, Chief (L), FBR and Nayyar Shafiq, Chief (Tariff)
Respondent(s) by: Farhat Nawaz Lodhi, Advocate Supreme Court
Present: SYED MANSOOR ALI SHAH, JAMAL KHAN MANDOKHAIL AND ATHAR MINALLAH JJ
ORDER

ATHAR MINALLAH, JUSTICE:--- Leave in this matter was granted vide order dated 06.8.2015 to consider questions of law that had arisen from the judgment of the High Court, dated 22.12.2014.2. The High Court had answered the questions of law proposed in the reference application filed under section 196 of the Customs Act 1969 ("Act of 1969") in favour of the tax payer and against the Department. The controversy was regarding determination of the correct classification of goods imported by M/s K.S.Sulemanji Esmailji and sons (Pvt.) Ltd., Karachi ("respondent-company"). The latter had imported twenty six consignments which were described at the import stage as "BOPP" Printed Laminated Packaging Film (Metalized) ["imported goods"]. The respondent-company was granted the facility of clearance of goods under the 'Automated Clearance Procedure,' which enabled the importer to clear the imported consignments without subjecting them to examination. Only in the case of two consignments was the norm...