Sindh High Court
2025
THLN 3289
2025 PTD 1410
Laws Cited
Income Tax Ordinance, 2001 | Constitution of Pakistan, 1973
Sections
99D, Notification SRO 1588(I) of 2023 | 77, 260

NATIONAL BANK OF PAKISTAN through Authorized Attorney

VS

FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN through Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Islamabad and 2 others (And connected matters, particularized in the Schedule1 hereto.)

Petitioner(s) by: Muhammad Farogh Naseem, Khalid Jawed Khan, Qazi Umair Ali, Lubna Pervez, Mariam Salahuddin, Shahrukh Farogh Naseem, Sagar Ladhani, Abdul Rehman Adeed, Saima Anjum, Pooja Kalpana, M. Umer Akhund, Uzair Qadir Shoro, Syed Muhammad Aijaz and Muhammad Imran Khan
Respondent(s) by: Shahzaib Masud, Ahmed Mujtaba and Saqib Soomro for the Federal Board of Revenue. Zia-ul-Haq Makhdoom and Mirza Nasar Ahmed, Additional Attorney General for Respondents. Kashif Nazeer and Alizeh Bashir, Assistant Attorney Generals
Present: Agha Faisal and Abdul Mubeen Lakho, JJ
JUDGMENT

A tax was imposed upon windfall2 gains of the banking sector, demonstrated to have been realized on account of sudden foreign currency fluctuations. The vires of the law was assailed in 2023 and by virtue of the interim orders obtained the effect of the law stood suspended.Historical perspective2. The imposition of windfall tax is certainly not a new phenomenon, either internationally or even domestically. The United Kingdom enacted the Energy (Oil and Gas) Profits Levy Act, 2022 imposing windfall tax and thereafter the rate of tax was retrospectively increased from twenty five to thirty five percent. In the European Union, fifteen out of twenty seven countries imposed the levy in 2022-20233. Greece imposed a ninety percent windfall tax on electricity producers in 2022. Croatia imposed a thirty three percent windfall tax in 2022. Italy imposed a forty percent windfall tax on banking companies in 2023, having effect from financial year 20214.3. Closer to home, the Excess Profits Tax Act...