Welcome To Tax Help Line
FBR Introduces Anonymous Digital Tax Appeals System | TaxHelpLine

FBR Introduces Anonymous Digital Tax Appeals System

19-Nov-2026
FBR Introduces Anonymous Digital Tax Appeals System

FBR Introduces Anonymous, Digitally Managed Tax Appeals System

ISLAMABAD: The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has rolled out a new faceless appeals mechanism for sales tax and federal excise matters, while proposing a comparable system for income tax disputes. Under the proposed arrangement, cases will be distributed automatically among commissioners without revealing the identities of the officials handling individual appeals to taxpayers or tax department representatives.

The proposed changes were announced through two separate notifications dated November 18, 2026. SRO 2134(I)/2026 amends the Sales Tax Rules, 2006, to introduce the mechanism for sales tax and federal excise appeals, whereas SRO 2136(I)/2026 outlines proposed changes to the Income Tax Rules, 2002.

Under the new system, eligible appeals will be submitted electronically through FBR's Iris portal or another approved digital platform. Cases will then be distributed among appellate units using a randomised, automated and continuously adjustable allocation process, replacing the conventional manual assignment method for covered disputes.

The identities of the commissioners and appellate units responsible for deciding cases will remain confidential throughout the proceedings. This restriction will apply to taxpayers, their authorised representatives and departmental respondents, including at the time the final decision is delivered.

Additional safeguards will apply to virtual hearings. Commissioners will not appear visually on screen, and their voices will be electronically altered to prevent their identification.

Both frameworks require hearings to take place through video conferencing or protected electronic communication channels, removing the need for taxpayers to appear physically before the deciding officials. Filing notices, presenting arguments, submitting supporting documents, providing evidence and exchanging official correspondence will also take place through digital channels.

Taxpayers will still be able to request decisions based entirely on their written arguments. However, the departmental respondent must first receive an opportunity to provide its observations, followed by a chance for the appellant to respond.

Individuals who lack internet connectivity will not be excluded from the process. They will be able to attend online hearings through designated facilities at the nearest Field Operations Wing office, which will arrange the necessary assistance and access.

For sales tax and federal excise matters, the revised rules will cover appeals handled by the National Faceless Centre under Section 45C of the Sales Tax Act, 1990. This includes challenges against decisions issued by officers working within the Centre, alongside additional appeal categories that FBR may designate.

Federal excise disputes falling under Section 33 of the Federal Excise Act, 2005, will also be included whenever they are processed through the designated Centre.

Meanwhile, the proposed income tax provisions will extend to appeals filed under Section 127 of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, and handled by the relevant Centre under Section 129A. These will include challenges to orders issued by its officials and other categories subsequently approved by the Board.

Both arrangements envisage specialised Appeals Wings made up of separate appellate units led by commissioners. Overall administrative oversight will remain with FBR's Member (Legal) Inland Revenue.

Officials from other departments within the respective Centres will be barred from interfering with commissioners' decisions or exercising authority over how individual appeals are heard and determined.

The rules also establish restrictions to prevent conflicts of interest. Officers involved in the original audit, tax assessment, quality control exercise or issuance of the disputed order will be disqualified from deciding an appeal concerning that same matter.

Similarly, commissioners having personal or financial connections to a particular dispute must electronically disclose the conflict and withdraw from the case. The appeal will subsequently be assigned to another eligible official.

FBR and the relevant Centre will retain the authority to shift cases between appellate units to manage workloads and support impartial proceedings. However, transfers made after a hearing has started must be supported by written reasons. In such circumstances, the taxpayer may also seek a fresh hearing.

The notifications introduce digital procedures for applications requesting temporary suspension of tax recovery while an appeal is under consideration.

Under the sales tax arrangement, stay applications must be scheduled for an electronic hearing within two working days of submission. The assigned commissioner will then have seven working days from the hearing's scheduling date to issue a decision.

For income tax disputes, the draft provisions continue to rely on the existing deadlines contained in Rule 76G of the Income Tax Rules instead of establishing separate time limits.

Departmental representatives will ordinarily be required to submit detailed, paragraph-by-paragraph responses within seven days of receiving a request. Commissioners may, however, allow a different timeframe where necessary.

If a case requires further documentation or on-site verification, the concerned Field Operations Wing will review the relevant material and upload its findings electronically. This will allow the appellate process to continue without requiring the parties to attend an in-person hearing before the deciding commissioner.

The sales tax amendments further clarify that additional investigations carried out during appeal proceedings will not provide grounds for sending a case back for a fresh decision by the original authority.

All virtual hearing proceedings will be digitally recorded and preserved as part of the official case record.

Final rulings, official notices and directions will be produced through FBR's electronic system and authenticated with a Digital Identification Number (DIN). The documents will not carry the deciding commissioner's name, official position or signature.

Under the amended sales tax provisions, an order placed in a taxpayer's electronic account will be considered legally served. The proposed income tax rules similarly recognise delivery through the taxpayer's designated online account.

If a taxpayer challenges the decision before the Appellate Tribunal, the relevant order will be identified through its appeal reference and DIN rather than the name of the commissioner responsible for issuing it.

The framework also retains existing legal provisions allowing qualifying taxpayers to approach the Appellate Tribunal directly where permitted under the applicable law.

Appeals already pending before commissioners when the new arrangements take effect will generally remain with their existing officers unless FBR directs otherwise. If a case is reassigned, the incoming appellate unit will continue proceedings from the point previously reached.

Both notifications also address technical disruptions affecting electronic submissions. If FBR officially verifies that a portal malfunction prevented an appeal, application or response from being filed within the prescribed deadline, the disruption will qualify as sufficient cause under the relevant legal provisions concerning filing delays.

The sales tax and federal excise amendments will become operational on dates to be announced separately by FBR, which may introduce the system for different appeal categories at different times. The income tax amendments, however, are still at the draft stage, with the Board inviting objections and recommendations within three days of their publication in the official Gazette.

About Us

This website has been developed with good faith to create facilities for the people.Your ID Password and access to our website is for a specific period or temporary, it may be suspended at any time without telling any reason.Your ID Password or access does not create any your rights or liability onto owner of the website.

Contact

Office # 3-6, Ground Floor Idrees Chamber ,Talpur Road Karachi

info@taxhelplines.com.pk

+ 92 314-4062161

021-32462161

+ 92 305-2561915

© 2023 Copyright: Taxhelplines.com.pk