Welcome To Tax Help Line
PRIME Warns FBR Tax Split Could Hurt Businesses | TaxHelpLine

PRIME Warns FBR Tax Split Could Hurt Businesses

19-Nov-2026
PRIME Warns FBR Tax Split Could Hurt Businesses

PRIME Warns FBR's Tax Separation Could Encourage Evasion and Raise Business Costs

ISLAMABAD: The Policy Research Institute of Market Economy (PRIME) has raised concerns over the Federal Board of Revenue's (FBR) move to split sales tax and income tax administration, warning that the decision could create opportunities for tax avoidance, increase business expenses and discourage companies from joining the documented economy, according to The Express Tribune.

In an assessment released on Wednesday, the research organisation questioned the reversal of a reform introduced in 2009, which had brought income tax, sales tax and federal excise functions under the Inland Revenue Service (IRS) to strengthen coordination and eliminate overlapping administrative responsibilities.

Under the revised structure, sales tax and federal excise matters will be handled independently of income tax administration. FBR has named Dr Muhammad Sarmad Qureshi as the inaugural Member for Sales Tax and Federal Excise, while Muhammad Anwar has been appointed as chief. Dedicated personnel are expected to take up their assignments from next month.

PRIME believes the division could weaken the tax department's ability to compare business figures reported in sales tax and income tax declarations. Without effective coordination, inconsistencies between the two sets of records and potentially undeclared earnings could escape scrutiny.

The organisational change comes amid concerns about declining domestic sales tax receipts. Collections from local sales fell by 1.7% during the previous financial year, even as revenue generated from sales tax on imported goods recorded a 17% increase.

The institute also highlighted the additional administrative burden that could fall on registered manufacturers, importers and distributors. Businesses may have to deal with separate commissioners, multiple official notices and potentially conflicting interpretations of transactions that fall under different tax jurisdictions.

According to PRIME, these complications could increase the expense of meeting tax obligations and make formal registration less appealing to enterprises that currently operate outside the documented system.

Rather than treating administrative restructuring as the main solution, the think tank identified Pakistan's divided value-added tax framework as a major underlying problem. Under the existing arrangement, the federal government taxes goods while provincial authorities collect taxes on services, with varying rates, filing requirements and exemption policies.

PRIME has therefore proposed introducing a unified value-added tax covering both goods and services, supported by a reduced common rate and a smaller number of exemptions, instead of creating further divisions within tax administration.

The research body further pointed out that the fall in domestic sales tax revenue was largely concentrated in three areas: electrical energy, cotton yarn and natural gas. Tax receipts from these sectors are closely linked to changes in consumption levels, industrial output and energy prices.

The concerns have emerged despite multiple attempts to reform FBR and substantial international financial assistance to Pakistan. The country's tax-to-GDP ratio has remained at 10.3% over the last two financial years, considerably below the government's stated objective of reaching 15%.

Separately, findings from recent competency evaluations conducted by FBR reportedly highlighted significant gaps in officers' technical knowledge of tax administration. Only 15 out of 150 assessed officials demonstrated the ability to independently issue sales tax orders, while just 14 of 143 achieved a similar standard in income tax matters.

The results were also weak among officers assessed in both disciplines. Out of 139 officials who participated in the two evaluations, only four satisfied the required competency benchmark in both sales tax and income tax.

An additional 65 officers were considered capable of preparing sales tax notices or orders, while 72 demonstrated comparable abilities in income tax matters, according to the reported assessment findings.

About Us

This website has been developed with good faith to create facilities for the people.Your ID Password and access to our website is for a specific period or temporary, it may be suspended at any time without telling any reason.Your ID Password or access does not create any your rights or liability onto owner of the website.

Contact

Office # 3-6, Ground Floor Idrees Chamber ,Talpur Road Karachi

info@taxhelplines.com.pk

+ 92 314-4062161

021-32462161

+ 92 305-2561915

© 2023 Copyright: Taxhelplines.com.pk