Welcome To Tax Help Line
FTO Orders FBR to Refund Payments for Three Damaged Lots | TaxHelpLine

FTO Orders FBR to Refund Payments for Three Damaged Lots

13-Nov-2026
FTO Orders FBR to Refund Payments for Three Damaged Lots

FTO Directs FBR to Return Payments for Three Deteriorated Auction Lots

Federal Tax Ombudsman (FTO) Zafar Hijazi has instructed the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) to reimburse a successful customs auction bidder for three lots of goods that deteriorated while remaining in departmental storage for an extended period.

In a written ruling issued on Thursday, the ombudsman ordered the Collector of Customs, Appraisement, Karachi, to accelerate the refund process. The decision followed an internal departmental assessment that confirmed the goods were in an unsatisfactory state, with loose bales and an unpleasant smell.

The disagreement stems from a customs auction conducted on February 13, 2024, featuring 42 lots of second-hand clothing and household goods with a combined estimated value of Rs72.89 million.

The successful bidder took delivery of 30 lots, but the remaining 12 lots, stored in 16 containers, became the centre of a dispute over their physical condition and handover.

The purchaser requested cancellation of the outstanding lots along with reimbursement of the payments made, arguing that the goods already received had also suffered deterioration and damage, leaving them unsuitable for commercial purposes.

Departmental records indicate that the earnest money deposited for four of the disputed lots had previously been returned.

Customs authorities separately admitted that three fully paid lots had deteriorated while being kept in storage. The department accepted responsibility for refunding the payments received against these particular lots.

However, the refund demand covering five additional fully paid lots was turned down. Customs officials maintained that these goods remained in deliverable condition and were still suitable for collection.

The department argued that the bidder had not taken possession of these five lots despite receiving multiple notices instructing him to collect the goods.

During its examination of the complaint, the FTO referred to Rule 65 of the Customs Rules, 2001, which establishes that customs auctions operate on an 'as-is-where-is' basis. Under this arrangement, successful bidders generally cannot cancel an accepted purchase simply because the goods later turn out to be commercially undesirable.

The ombudsman also pointed out that concerns raised about the quality of previously collected merchandise could not automatically prove that all outstanding auction lots had suffered comparable damage or deterioration.

Nevertheless, the FTO determined that the customs department's own assessment had established sufficient evidence of deterioration in the case of three specific lots. This admission provided legitimate grounds for returning the money received against those goods.

Consequently, the ombudsman instructed the Collector of Customs, Appraisement, Karachi, to fast-track the reimbursement of payments for the three lots whose damaged condition had been officially acknowledged by the department.

About Us

This website has been developed with good faith to create facilities for the people.Your ID Password and access to our website is for a specific period or temporary, it may be suspended at any time without telling any reason.Your ID Password or access does not create any your rights or liability onto owner of the website.

Contact

Office # 3-6, Ground Floor Idrees Chamber ,Talpur Road Karachi

info@taxhelplines.com.pk

+ 92 314-4062161

021-32462161

+ 92 305-2561915

© 2023 Copyright: Taxhelplines.com.pk